Guides Content strategy and the newsroom
Why don't your videos show up in Google?
Why Google stopped showing most article videos in its results, how YouTube came to dominate video in Google and AI answers, and what that means for publishers and brands investing in video.
Plenty of publishers and brands now put video on almost every article. Far fewer of those videos ever appear in Google.
That’s not usually because the video is bad. In 2023 Google changed which pages it treats as video pages, and most article pages no longer qualify. At the same time, YouTube has become the domain Google’s AI answers cite most. A video can be well made, widely embedded and still close to invisible in search.
What changed in 2023?
Google narrowed video results to pages where the video is the point of the page.
In April 2023 Google started showing video thumbnails in its main results only when the video is the main content of the page. In December 2023 it extended the change to Video mode, the video tab in Google’s results. Google said a qualifying page is one where “the video is above the fold, it’s prominent, and the main purpose of the page is to watch that video.”
Google gave examples of pages that don’t qualify:
- “A blog post where the video is complementary to the text rather than the primary content of the page”
- “A product details page with a complementary video”
- “A video category page that lists multiple videos of equal prominence”
Videos on those pages now show as “No video indexed” in Search Console. Google told site owners to “expect to see a decrease in the number of pages with indexed videos.”
In my experience, that rules out most publisher articles with a video in them. The video may still help readers. But on its own, it’s unlikely to earn a place in Google’s video results.
Where does video in Google come from now?
Increasingly, from YouTube.
Ahrefs says that, in its Brand Radar data, YouTube is the most cited domain in Google’s AI Overviews, and that its citations have grown 34% over six months. In an analysis of 863,000 searches published in March 2026, Ahrefs found YouTube made up 5.6% of all the pages AI Overviews cited, and 18.2% of cited pages that didn’t rank in Google’s top 100 for the same search. In other words, YouTube videos get cited even where they don’t rank.
At the same time, Google is showing fewer video carousels in its ordinary results. In August 2026 Search Engine Roundtable reported Semrush data showing the carousel had fallen from just over 30% of searches to under 20%. Jonas Sickler, who tracks 1,200 searches for big brand names, saw it fall to about 5%.
In my view, the route from a video to Google is narrowing, and much of what’s left runs through YouTube.
YouTube or your own site?
This is the real decision.
YouTube brings reach, and on the evidence above it’s the domain Google’s AI Overviews cite most. But YouTube keeps the relationship with the viewer, much of the data and a share of the advertising revenue. Your own site keeps the reader, but most of your video there is unlikely to appear in Google’s video results at all.
I’ve written about who is winning that audience. In Who won the midterms on YouTube? I tracked more than 10,000 election videos and found creators beat most newsrooms. And in The video-first world is already here I set out why newsrooms need to learn from creators and treat video as a strategy, not an add-on. The same goes for audio, which I cover in Can people find your podcast through Google and AI search?
Why it matters
Plenty of publishers add video to articles for the advertising revenue, not for search, and that can be a sound decision. But video is expensive. In my experience, many teams judge it by plays on their own site, without asking whether anyone could find it outside the site. If a video can only be found by people who are already reading the article, it isn’t bringing in a new audience.
Getting the strategy wrong costs twice. You spend on video that search never sees, and, in my view, you miss the platform where your audience and Google’s AI answers are increasingly looking.
What the right answer depends on
The right balance depends on what your video is for, whether you need the reach of YouTube or the relationship of your own site, how your pages are built, how your video is funded, and what you want viewers to do next.
How I help
I look at where your video is found today, across your site, Google, YouTube and AI answers, and compare it with the competitors and creators taking your audience. You come away with a clear view of what your video is earning and missing, and a plan in order of impact for your site, your YouTube channel and your wider content.
That’s part of my content strategy and AI visibility consulting.
Investing in video and not sure it's being found? I'll go through it with you on a free 30-minute call.
Got a question first? See the questions clients ask me.
Explore services