Guides AI search and AI visibility
Why does ChatGPT recommend your competitors and not you?
Why AI assistants name some brands and leave out others, what the research says matters, and why most of the reasons aren't on your own website.
Ask ChatGPT for the best providers in your field and it names three, five or ten. Your competitors are there. You aren’t.
It’s one of the most common questions I’m asked, and it’s frustrating because it feels arbitrary. It isn’t entirely. But most of the reasons a competitor gets named sit outside their website, which is why changing your own pages alone often isn’t enough.
Is there such a thing as ranking in ChatGPT?
Not in the way there is in Google. AI assistants don’t keep a fixed list for each question. They write a new answer every time.
In early 2026 SparkToro and Gumshoe tested this in the US. Volunteers ran 12 prompts through ChatGPT, Claude and Google’s AI Overviews, 2,961 times in total. The authors estimate that ChatGPT or Google’s AI Overviews would give the same list of brands twice in 100 runs less than 1% of the time, and the same list in the same order roughly once in 1,000 runs.
What did hold steady was how often each brand appeared. Some brands were named in almost every answer, wherever they sat in the list. One of the authors works for Gumshoe, which sells AI visibility tracking, and the post says so. But the finding matches what anyone who runs the same prompt twice will see.
So “where do we rank in ChatGPT?” is the wrong question, and a single screenshot tells you very little about where you stand.
Where AI assistants get their recommendations
An assistant draws on two things when it recommends a brand.
What it learned in training. Models are trained on huge amounts of web text. Brands that have been written about widely, over years, are more familiar to the model. This changes slowly, and only when new models are released.
What it finds when it searches. For many questions, assistants search the web and read a handful of pages before answering. For “who’s the best…” questions, those pages are often comparison lists, reviews, directories and forum threads. If your competitors are on the lists the assistant reads and you aren’t, the answer will reflect that.
Neither source is your website alone. Your site matters, but mostly as one voice among many.
What the research says matters
The largest study I know of is Ahrefs’ analysis of 75,000 brands in Google’s AI Overviews, published in 2025. It doesn’t cover ChatGPT, but it’s the best large-scale evidence there is on what AI answers reward.
| Measure | Correlation with AI Overview mentions |
|---|---|
| Brand mentions on other websites | 0.664 |
| Links to the brand that use its name | 0.527 |
| Searches for the brand name | 0.392 |
| Backlinks | 0.218 |
The three strongest are all about what happens off your website. Plain backlinks, the traditional SEO currency, came well behind.
Two more findings stand out. About a quarter of the brands (26%) weren’t mentioned in AI Overviews at all. And brands in the top quarter for web mentions averaged more than ten times as many AI Overview mentions as brands in the next quarter down. The gap between the brands that get named and the ones that don’t is wide.
Ahrefs is clear that these are correlations, not proof of cause. Bigger brands get mentioned more everywhere, including in AI answers. But the pattern fits how assistants work: they repeat what the web says about you.
Why a competitor gets named instead of you
When I compare a brand with the competitors AI assistants prefer, the reasons usually sit in three places: what the rest of the web says about each of them, how clearly each describes what it does, and whether the assistants can read their sites at all. Some brands block AI search bots without knowing it, which I explain in Should you block AI crawlers?
It’s usually several things at once, and which matter most differs by sector and by assistant. That’s why copying what a competitor seems to be doing rarely closes the gap.
Why it matters even when nobody clicks
AI assistants still send most sites far less traffic than Google. It would be easy to conclude that being left out doesn’t matter.
But recommendations shape shortlists before anyone visits a website. Someone who asks ChatGPT for three options and then searches for one of them by name may show up in your analytics as a branded search or a direct visit, not as AI traffic. If you’re not on the shortlist, you never see the visit you lost. And because the gap between named and unnamed brands is so wide, it can grow if nobody acts.
What the right answer depends on
There’s no single fix, because the reasons differ from brand to brand. What will make a difference for you depends on what your customers ask, which assistants they use, which sources those assistants trust in your sector, and how your brand is described across the web today.
How I help
I measure how often you and your competitors are named across the assistants your customers use, and trace why. You come away with a clear picture of why you’re being left out and a plan ordered by impact, with the changes most likely to get you named first.
That’s the core of my AI visibility consulting.
Want to know how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Google's AI name you against your competitors, and why? I'll talk it through with you on a free 30-minute call.
Got a question first? See the questions clients ask me.
Explore services